Stick A Fork In The ‘Housing Recovery’ (Spoiler Alert: Blame Record Student Debt)

Stick A Fork In The “Housing Recovery” (Spoiler Alert: Blame Record Student Debt) (ZeroHedge, March 20, 2014):

The chart below from Bank of America – showing the progression of first-time US homebuyers in recent months – should scare everyone who still believes that there is some sort of “housing recovery” in the US.

First Time Homebuyers

What this chart tells us is that an increasingly greater amount of existing homes is being sold not to people who want to live in them, but speculators who are merely seeking to flip to a greater fool, or worse, to Chinese and Russian olilgarchs who are simply seeking a place where to park hot money or simply launder other ill-gotten cash.

The NAR essentially confirmed this (something Zero Hedge readers have known for nearly a year), when it reported that “all-cash sales comprised 35 percent of transactions in February, up from 33 percent in January and 32 percent in February 2013. Individual investors, who account for many cash sales, purchased 21 percent of homes in February, compared with 20 percent in January; they were 22 percent in February 2013. Seventy-three percent of investors paid cash in February.

Read that last sentence again: 73% of investors, i.e. speculators who now account for a greater portion of total purchasers than first time home buyers, paid cash!

So what explains this collapse in the traditional housing pathway, where people buy houses to live in them? Simple. Record debt. Only not the credit card debt variety which historically was the biggest impediment to large purchases and was among the reasons for the 2007 credit bubble pop. This time it is all student debt.

NAR President Steve Brown, co-owner of Irongate, Inc., Realtors in Dayton, Ohio, said student debt appears to be a factor in the weak level of first-time buyers. “The biggest problems for first-time buyers are tight credit and limited inventory in the lower price ranges,” he said. “However, 20 percent of buyers under the age of 33, the prime group of first-time buyers, delayed their purchase because of outstanding debt. In our recent consumer survey, 56 percent of younger buyers who took longer to save for a downpayment identified student debt as the biggest obstacle.

Brown notes the survey results are for recent homebuyers. “It’s clear there are other people who would like to buy a home that are not in the market because of debt issues, so we can expect a lingering impact of delayed home buying,” Brown added.

As a reminder, in Q4 student debt rose to a record $1.08 trillion, and continues to rise at a breakneck pace.

But… but… what happened to the whole “the US consumer has deleveraged and can’t wait to go on a spending spree” fable again?

Source: Bank of America, NAR

1 thought on “Stick A Fork In The ‘Housing Recovery’ (Spoiler Alert: Blame Record Student Debt)”

  1. Spending is only enjoyable when you have more money coming in. When an entire nation is worried about the length of their current job, and how long it takes to get another one…….every cent spent is disturbing. It is a psychology, and it has taken over the US… can take decades before it passes, and for millions, it may never end.
    As a girl, I remember people who lived through the Great Depression, and I saw the same attitudes. If 70% of GDP depends on consumer spending (I no longer believe that number, it is obsolete, just like the concept of a world currency standard), we are in deep trouble. People no longer spend their weekends and holidays at the mall…..the mood has shifted.
    If one worries income could decline or vanish over the next few months, they won’t be spending unnecessary dollars.
    The psychology has changed radically.
    Also, Obama care has made it really hard on the independent contractor or small business members. It is fine for those who work for big corporations, but a bitch for those who are on their own. Less money in the pockets of millions.
    I spoke with a friend of mine who is a nurse practitioner. She is raising four children (her husband died) and her insurance has doubled from $1000 a month to $2000.
    Reason, they have to pay for those who cannot. She cannot afford it, $24K a year is more than many people make.
    This is unbelievable. Instead of making the insurance companies come up with something, Obama Care makes certain they lose nothing, but gain 50 million captive customers……if they don’t join, they are hounded and fined by the IRS.
    The IRS can freeze your bank accounts, and make it impossible for people to live. They have way too much power, and they don’t care who they hurt. Now, they can nail you if you don’t buy private insurance. This ought to be unconstitutional, but we don’t have one any longer.
    This is a total mess. Nothing works any longer.


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.